19.11.2026 Critique of NYT Report: Insufficient Evidence Linking Iran's Dams to Military Facilities
In a new commentary, Professor Mohammad Reza Farzanegan examines methodological shortcomings in a New York Times report on Iran's dams and missile sites and presents an independent correlation analysis using data from Iran's 31 provinces.
In a new commentary published on Substack, Professor Mohammad Reza Farzanegan critically examines a New York Times (NYT) investigation published on November 16, 2026. The report suggests that some of Iran's extensive dam and water-transfer projects may have been developed to support underground missile facilities.
Farzanegan identifies several methodological shortcomings in the report. In particular, he argues that geographical proximity between dams and military installations does not establish a causal relationship. Both types of infrastructure may be located in similar geographical areas for different reasons. Political and economic considerations may also explain the construction of large infrastructure projects in Iran.
To examine the proposed geographical relationship, Farzanegan conducts an independent empirical analysis using ACLED airstrike data and two international dam inventories, Global Dam Watch and Global Dam Tracker. He calculates four Pearson correlation coefficients across Iran's 31 provinces, comparing the provincial distribution of dams with reported airstrikes during the June 2025 and February–April 2026 conflicts.
None of the four estimated correlations is statistically significant at the 5% level. These preliminary findings cannot establish or rule out connections between individual dams and military facilities. However, they highlight the need for more systematic empirical evidence to assess the geographical relationship suggested in the NYT investigation.
The commentary also discusses the potential consequences of insufficiently supported claims about civilian infrastructure during armed conflict. Farzanegan emphasizes the importance of carefully examining such claims, particularly given the potential humanitarian, economic, and environmental consequences of attacks on dams and other essential infrastructure.
Read the full commentary: https://mohammadrezafarzanegan.substack.com/p/irans-dams-and-missile-sites-the
Contact
Prof. M.R. Farzanegan